I had the same dilemma but stuck with my surgeons suggestion of moderate plus. I would always say just go with what they say as they are professionals and experts in their work and give their suggestions based on the best fit for your body. It’s all very well and good having a set idea in your mind of what you want but you have to take into consideration of what’s best for you as not everyone is the same. Discuss what look and size you want to achieve and they will decide on the best size, profile and placement that will achieve this but that is also suitable for your body.
I thought I wanted high profile as I was worried about them sitting too low but my surgeon suggested moderate plus because I have a wider breast. If they put a high profile in which is a narrower implant it probably wouldn’t of looked right on my body. I would honestly say although I know it’s our bodies and we think we know best, we don’t because we are not surgeons!
I’m 4 days po now and although I’m all strapped up and can’t see them properly they definitely look high enough! X